If you are like me, you’re wondering how Notre Dame football is ranked below multiple SEC teams that have two-losses to the Irish’s one in the College Football Playoff rankings.
On Wednesday, On3’s Brett McMurphy reported that the that a former athletic director was was part of the ranking process “asked a university employee for the employee’s own Top 25 every week before voting on the rankings,” which makes you wonder. How much football are these members actually watching?
Are they really relying on a random staff member to help them accumulate their rankings? It’s just so odd, and clearly not the right way to go about formulating which teams should be included in the 12-team playoff. While the employee did say that “no one told them whether it influenced the AD’s ballot.”
Sure, many athletic directors have plenty on their plates, but being part of the CFP committee required a big commitment. If they aren’t willing to do the legwork to properly rank the teams, then maybe they shouldn’t be part of the group.
After what we’ve seen this season, it’s fair to say there there needs to be a board that solely focuses on watching games each week and creating the rankings. They should be independent of a conference or school, but it still would be hard to avoid some favoritism. It’s a broken system and needs a fix, but who knows when that actually will be the case.
NEW: A CFP selection committee member had a university employee send them a personal Top 25 each Sunday before voting on playoff rankings - & there's no rule against it 👀
— Brett McMurphy (@Brett_McMurphy) November 18, 2026
"If that's their only work, that's a concern," a former commitee member told @On3https://t.co/nohSueX6A3
Contact/Follow us @IrishWireND on X (formerly Twitter) and like our page on Facebook to follow ongoing coverage of Notre Dame news, notes and opinions.
Follow Mike on X: @MikeFChen
This article originally appeared on Fighting Irish Wire: CFP committees odd ranking process has been uncovered






