
Madden is now streaming on Prime Video.
David O. Russell’s erratically directed Madden is an assemblage of montages in search of a story. Is Madden about the relationship between Oakland Raiders coach John Madden and team owner Al Davis? Is it about John’s struggles to be a husband and father when football’s no longer consuming his life? Is it about John proving himself as an announcer? Is it about the creation of EA’s Madden video game franchise?
Madden the movie casts a wide net around all those topics while never satisfactorily exploring them in any real depth or detail, the whole endeavor playing out like SNL skit after SNL skit without anything ever feeling emotionally genuine. It’s one frantically edited, half-explored sequence set to vintage needledrops after another.
Nicolas Cage is packed into a fat suit and prosthetics as the NFL icon, coming across more like a stage actor starring in Shrek the Musical than a real flesh-and-blood person. Yes, John Madden was an over-the-top figure in real life but the movie and Cage turn him into a cartoon character or the big, bumbling oafish dad in a sitcom. (Will Ferrell was reportedly up to play Madden before Cage.)
Christian Bale is similarly reduced to makeup and mugging as Al Davis, only occasionally hinting at a real person underneath that greasy, gaudy exterior. Davis’ drive to “just win, baby” certainly fed Madden’s hunger for the game and for victory on the field. Their symbiotic relationship here tries to be the film’s main focus, but the slight story never digs much deeper than the superficial.
John and Al seem made for each other but there's almost a manipulative pusher and junkie dynamic at play. At one point, John tries to break free from Al’s hold over him, but the film is reluctant to show any of its characters in too negative a light.
For both Madden and Davis, it’s their wives – Virginia Madden and Carol Davis, respectively – who help illuminate their larger-than-life spouse’s vulnerabilities, with Kathryn Hahn faring better than Sienna Miller in having an impact. As Virginia, Hahn finds the humor and heart in an otherwise underwritten character (Miller’s Carol is the far more thankless role). Still, Hahn’s is arguably the most emotionally genuine performance in the film.
After a few teases early on, the last half hour of the movie hones in on the creation of the Madden video game. This sequence finally offers the movie a bit more focus and some conflict between John and Al, as the latter doesn’t want John to contribute his time and knowledge to what he deems an inconsequential endeavor when he could come back to work for the Raiders. The SNL skit vibe of the whole film isn’t helped by the casting of John Mulaney as EA’s Trip Hawkins, with the entire EA staff and their endeavor depicted as a bunch of nerds who learn how to be jocks thanks to John Madden’s football know-how.
It’s all pretty condescending. The EA staff are all portrayed as stereotypical geeks, right down to their costuming. In reality, EA’s video game designers of that time were depicted as being akin to rock musicians, not hapless dweebs. Still, there might have at least been a fun Revenge of the Nerds-style film in here had Madden chosen to just chronicle this one chapter of John Madden’s life. Instead, the film is merely a highlight reel, with none of Madden’s accomplishments feeling any more special than the rest.
Between 2022’s Amsterdam and now Madden, director David O. Russell has lost his filmmaking footing after a decade-plus of solid movies (Three Kings, The Fighter, Silver Linings Playbook, American Hustle). Madden is bewildering in its sloppiness and inability to commit to telling a focused story that does its beloved subject justice.






